AI’s Takeover of Google Search: What’s Happening? 

Google’s AI Overviews (formerly known as Search Generative Experience or SGE) are redefining how search results are delivered. Instead of the classic list of blue links, AI Overviews provide summarized answers to user queries, often pulling from multiple sources and displaying them prominently at the top of the Search Engine Results Page (SERP).   

This shift prioritizes user convenience but poses challenges for businesses relying on organic traffic. Here’s how AI is impacting key areas: 

• SEO Evolution: Traditional SEO focused on ranking high for keywords and earning clicks. Now, AI Overviews emphasize content quality, relevance, and structure, as Google’s algorithms (like BERT and RankBrain) better understand user intent. Websites must align with Google’s E-E-A-T principles (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness) to be featured in AI summaries.  

• Traffic Shifts: AI Overviews can reduce click-through rates (CTRs) by 18-64% for some websites, especially for informational queries where users get answers directly on the SERP. Zero-click searches—where users don’t visit any site—are on the rise, hitting organic traffic hard.  Traditionally, quality content = traffic.  That is no longer the case.  It will continue to become more challenging to get traffic based on quality content. 

On the upside, transactional traffic, such as when a user is ready to purchase something, higher quality traffic are being sent to e-commerce websites with better engagement rates.  

• Content Strategy Changes: AI favors in-depth, well-structured content that answers specific user intents. Generic lists or thin content are losing ground to comprehensive guides, expert-driven articles, and multimedia content like videos or infographics.   

Markets Feeling the Heat 

Not all industries are impacted equally. AI Overviews hit hardest where users seek quick, informational answers or straightforward data. Based on recent analyses, here are the most affected markets: 

Publishing and Media: News sites, blogs, and content-heavy publishers (40-75% of traffic from organic search) face steep traffic drops as AI summarizes articles or news snippets directly on the SERP. 

 Affiliate Marketing: Sites ranking for “best [product]” queries lose clicks when AI compiles product comparisons or buyer guides, crushing affiliate revenue. 

 Travel and Hospitality: Queries like “things to do in Cincinnati” or “best hotels for conferences” now trigger AI-generated lists, reducing visits to travel blogs or booking platforms. 

 E-commerce: While commercial/transactional searches “buy xyz product” are less affected, product review sites and comparison pages lose traffic to AI summaries. 

 YMYL Sectors (Your Money, Your Life): Health, finance, and legal industries face cautious AI integration due to sensitivity, but complex queries (e.g., “tax benefits for manufacturing businesses”) still see AI-driven summaries, impacting niche advisory sites. 

Why It Matters to You 

For nearly all businesess, big and small, these changes hit your bottom line. Less website traffic means fewer leads, lower brand visibility, and reduced conversions. But don’t panic—AI isn’t the enemy. It’s a tool you can harness to thrive in this new digital era. Let’s explore strategies to combat these changes and keep your business soaring. 

Strategies to Combat AI-Driven Changes 

To stay visible and drive traffic in an AI-dominated search landscape, you need a proactive, multi-faceted approach. Here are five actionable strategies, tailored for businesses like yours, to adapt and succeed: 

1. Create High-Quality, Authoritative Content

AI Overviews prioritize content that’s comprehensive, expert-driven, and aligned with user intent. Instead of churning out generic posts, focus on: 

• In-Depth Guides: Write detailed articles like “The Ultimate Guide to Choosing a Microsoft 365 Partner for Non-Profit Organizations” that answer specific questions thoroughly. 

• Expert Voices: Include insights from industry veterans (e.g., “Our Lead Metallurgist Explains Why Steel Outperforms Aluminum in High-Stress Applications”) to boost E-E-A-T. 

• Structured Data: Use schema markup to help AI algorithms understand your content, increasing the chance of being featured in AI Overviews. 

2. Optimize for Long-Tail Keywords and User Intent

• AI excels at answering complex, specific queries. Shift your keyword strategy to long-tail phrases that match user intent, such as: 

• “Best organic skincare products for sensitive skin” – User Intent is looking for high-quality skincare for sensitive skin.   

• “Budget-friendly vacation spots in Cincinnati” - User intent is planning a vacation to Cincinnati on a budget.  

These queries are less likely to be fully answered by AI Overviews, driving clicks to your site. You can also use tools like SEMrush or Ahrefs to identify high-potential long-tail keywords. 

3. Diversify Traffic Sources

Relying solely on Google is risky. It’s like putting all your eggs in one basket.  Spread your digital presence across multiple channels.  Be where your customers are.   

• Social Media: Share valuable, usable content on LinkedIn, Facebook or Twitter about industry trends or share the High-Quality, Authoritative Content you created.  You can use Social Media to share events, articles, or promotions.  It can also be a place you can engage with your customer community.   

• Email Marketing: Build a robust email list to directly reach customers with newsletters or product updates. 

• Influencer Marketing: Partner with industry influencers or trade publications to amplify your brand and earn backlinks. 

• Forums and User Generated Content (UGC) Platforms: Engage on Reddit or Quora with valuable insights answering specific industry questions that you have expertise in to drive referral traffic. 

4. Enhance SERP Presence with Digital PR 

AI Overviews often cite sources from high-authority domains. Boost your chances of being featured by: 

• Earning Media Mentions: Pitch proprietary research or unique insights to industry journals or local news outlets.  Consider offering to speak as expert at industry or local events.  This not only gets your brand out there, but positions you as the expert.   

• Building Backlinks: Secure links from reputable sites like trade associations or partner blogs to elevate your site’s authority.  Check their Domain Authority, and try to build links to sites that have a higher domain authority than yours.   

• Leveraging Reviews: Encourage positive customer reviews on platforms like Google Business Profile or Yelp to enhance trust signals.  Positive reviews can go a long way when a prospect is choosing to do business with you. 

5. Monitor and Adapt with Analytics 

AI’s impact varies by query and industry, so continuous monitoring is key. Use tools like: 

• Google Search Console: Track changes in impressions, clicks, and CTRs for keywords affected by AI Overviews.  Keep an eye on your Core Vitals to ensure your website is running at it’s best and loading quickly for all users.   

• Google Analytics: Track your website traffic, conversions, and most popular content.  Find out where visitors are coming from and what they are engaging on your site with the most.   

• Ahrefs: Identify which keywords trigger AI Overviews and adjust content accordingly. 

• Hotjar: Analyze user behavior on your site to optimize engagement and conversions.  This tracks visitors mouse movements on the site.   

Regularly update your content based on performance data to stay relevant and visible.  Overtime, you can learn which strategies work the best.   

The Silver Lining: Opportunities with AI 

While AI Overviews pose challenges, they also offer golden opportunities. Websites featured in AI summaries can see traffic boosts, especially if they rank lower in traditional results. Plus, AI tools like ChatGPT or Google’s Gemini can supercharge your content creation by suggesting keywords, drafting outlines, or analyzing competitors. By blending AI’s efficiency with human creativity, you can craft content that resonates with both algorithms and readers. 

Wrapping Up: Stay Agile, Stay Ahead 

AI is rewriting the rules of Google Search, SEO, and digital marketing, but it’s not the end of the road—it’s a new beginning. By creating high-quality content, targeting long-tail keywords, diversifying traffic sources, leveraging digital PR, and monitoring performance, you can navigate this AI-driven landscape and come out stronger. At ISOCNET, we’re here to help businesses, adapt and thrive in this evolving digital world. 

Talk To An Expert